Accessed 12th August 2013
Accessed 12th August 2013
's 60 million women that never were India
60 million women- that's nearly the entire population of the United Kingdom - are missing in India. Why?
Last Modified: 08 Aug 2013 15:25
Sunny Hundal is the author of the recently released e-book, India Dishonoured: Behind a Nation's War on Women and is a regular contributor to the Guardian and the New Statesman.
It has been nearly seven months since a young student was gang-raped in the
New Delhi, , and died
from her horrific injuries 13 days later on December 29, 2012. The fast-track
trial of the accused men has just re-started and the sentence is due any day
When thousands of Indians took to the streets to protest the inability of the establishment to protect women, they demanded not just a change in the law but in people's attitudes. But the watershed moment that many Indians hoped for doesn't seem to have arrived. And that may be because most Indians don't even recognise the extent of the problem in their own country.
Let's start with a figure: 60 million. That is nearly the entire population of the
. That is also the approximate number
of women "missing" in United
They have either been aborted before birth, killed once born, died of neglect
because they were girls, or perhaps murdered by their husband's
family for not paying enough dowry at marriage. India
That number isn't a wild exaggeration or a figure thoughtlessly plucked out of the air, but a matter of demographics. As far back as 1991, the economist Amartya Sen pointed out that
was missing 100 million womenbecause
of sex-selection and the poor attention paid to women. In 2005, it was estimated at 50 million Indian
women in the New York Times. But this isn't a new
In 1991, the Indian census showed an unprecedented drop of women in the sex-ratio. After running tests to check whether women had been under-counted, they found that a massive explosion in sex-selection during the 80s had led to a sharp drop in the number of girls being born. A report by Action Aid in 2009 ("Disappearing Daughters" [PDF]) found that in some villages in the state of
there were as few as 300 girls for every 1,000 boys.
had 37.25 million fewer women than men according to the 2011 Census. To match
the sexes equally and then increase the number of women to match the natural
sex-ratio would require around 60 to 70 million women. That is the number of
women missing. This phenomenon cannot be called anything less than genocide. India
So why isn't there more recognition of this mass tragedy? In my recently released e-book India Dishonoured: Behind a Nation's War on Women, I show that many Indians don't want to recognise the problem because it has become deeply ingrained in the culture.
This is illustrated with how the political establishment reacted to the gang-rape in
Initially, many politicians simply dismissed the protests on the
streets. Mohan Bhagwat, chief of the powerful Hindu nationalist
organisation Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), even said, "You go to
villages and forests of the country and there will be no such incidents of
gang-rape or sex crimes. They are prevalent in some urban belts." He went
on to criticise "western lifestyle" in cities for sexual assaults. New Delhi
Even the prime minister said nothing about the incident until a week later, despite the protests. Nevertheless an independently produced report commissioned by the government made excellent recommendations that were broadly adopted despite some exceptions. Marital rape, for example, is still legal there.
While changes in the law are welcome, they barely scratch the surface.
India and alone
represent nearly four out of every ten of all people on earth. Due to endemic
sex-selection in both countries, the imbalance of women and men there is
unprecedented in human history. China
the overall sex-ratio for young children has fallen to 916 girls per 1,000
boys, and had consistently gotten worse over the last 60 years. In 2012, India was named
the worst G20 country to be a woman in due to sex selection, infanticide and
Worse, the liberalisation of social attitudes and rising incomes over the last 20 years has, paradoxically, made the matter worse in many ways. While some Indian women have never had so much freedom, these changes are being accompanied by a huge backlash in the form of higher rates of rapes and assaults, and an establishment that has preferred to blame "western values" instead.
But the problem in
goes to the heart of cultural practices that have been around for centuries.
Culture doesn't just determine a country's laws and how well they are
implemented, it also discourages or encourages violence against women.
Practices such as paying dowry for brides, shunning divorced women, passing on
inheritances only to men, not putting girls through schools - are all part of
the problem. As families get richer, there is more pressure to pay out bigger
dowries for girls and they have more money to afford an abortion. India
According to one estimate, by 2020
will have an extra 28
million men of marriageable age. The social impact of such an imbalance is
unprecedented in history, and India
barely has a police force and judicial system that can cope with the current
Unless the country recognises the gravity of the problem and does more to protect half the population, the social impact will be felt in every aspect of Indian society for decades.
Sunny Hundal is the author of the recently released e-book,
Dishonoured: Behind a Nation's War on Women and is a regular contributor to the Guardian and the New Statesman. India
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy.